Skip links

Is Jacinta Allan’s Leadership in Jeopardy? Labor MPs Weigh a Shake-Up Amid Polling Woes


Growing Tensions Inside Victorian Labor

Weeks of quiet speculation have escalated within Victorian Labor as MPs and factional powerbrokers increasingly question Jacinta Allan’s future as leader.

Sources reveal that in hushed conversations across Parliament corridors, concerns have been raised over her political “baggage,” including:

  • Serving as deputy to Daniel Andrews
  • Oversight of the cancelled Commonwealth Games
  • Managing the Big Build project during a period of alleged corruption in the construction union

Polling Numbers Add Pressure

The most pressing issue for Allan may be her declining public support. Recent polling highlights a sharp drop in approval:

  • A DemosAU poll in the Herald Sun showed a net approval of -37%, making her the only state leader in negative territory
  • Resolve polling for The Age in February reflected similar figures, noting just one in five voters preferred her as premier
  • This represents Allan’s lowest support since taking over from Andrews in late 2023

Such statistics are fueling discussions within Labor about whether a leadership change is needed to improve the party’s prospects.


The Political Baggage

A Deputy with History

Allan’s time as Daniel Andrews’ deputy is being cited as a key factor by critics. Her association with past controversies, including delays and mismanagement in large-scale projects, is seen as a liability.

Handling of Corruption Issues

Some MPs argue that Allan hesitated to act decisively once corruption in the construction sector was revealed, creating a perception of inaction at a critical time. This has compounded doubts about her leadership credibility.


Internal Factional Dynamics

Quiet Discussions in Parliament

Labor insiders suggest that more than a dozen sources—including ministers and factional leaders—have been weighing her position. While some describe the chatter as mere gossip, others insist it reflects genuine concern about the party’s electoral future.

The debate is intensifying behind closed doors as Labor considers the best path forward to maintain stability and voter confidence.


Public Perception and Leadership Risk

Unpopular at a Critical Time

Allan’s negative polling coincides with other state Labor leaders enjoying high approval. This contrast has heightened internal unease and sparked discussions about potential replacements.

Political analysts note that leadership decisions are often driven by both perception and performance, and Allan’s declining popularity could be a tipping point.


What’s Next for Victorian Labor?

Possible Leadership Shake-Up

While no formal decision has been made, speculation suggests:

  • Labor may explore new leadership options if polling continues to decline
  • Internal factions will likely debate timing and candidates
  • Any change would aim to restore public confidence before upcoming elections

Watching for Signals

Allan’s next moves—public statements, policy decisions, and engagement with factions—will be closely scrutinized for signs of political maneuvering.


Final Thoughts

Jacinta Allan faces one of the most challenging periods of her leadership. With negative polling, lingering political baggage, and internal factional pressures, Labor is at a crossroads in Victoria. Whether the chatter remains gossip or becomes a real leadership challenge remains to be seen, but the coming months will be pivotal for both Allan and the party.


Leave a comment